If an airline convinces you to cancel your flight during a pandemic, does it get to keep your money? That’s what Lon Allan wants to know.
In March 2020, Lon was sitting at home, minding his own business when an email from United Airlines arrived. At first blush, it seemed the airline had concern for Lon’s possible need to cancel his upcoming flight over coronavirus. But scratch the surface, and the motivation behind this email becomes crystal clear. Unfortunately, Lon didn’t recognize the friendly overture wasn’t what it seemed until it was too late.
Now Lon wants help retrieving the $8,631 he paid for the flight that United Airlines convinced him to cancel.
But is that possible?
To say that the airline industry was hit hard by the coronavirus pandemic is an understatement. It forced airlines to cancel flights at a rate previously unimaginable. To avoid issuing the refunds that are required by law, the carriers got crafty. Lon’s tale illustrates one way airlines tried to sidestep those regulations.
Editor’s note: We originally published this article in April 2020. It was last updated for Consumer Rescue on November 5, 2022.
Planning a vacation before the pandemic
Lon and his wife intended to vacation for two weeks in Israel in the spring of 2020. They splurged on business class tickets for the 22-hour journey from San Francisco to Tel Aviv. The couple planned to fly in United Airlines’ Polaris cabin.
Although the tickets came at a premium, the Allans reasoned that the Polaris experience would be well worth it for the lengthy flight. After purchasing the $8,631 tickets, the duo printed the confirmation and happily looked forward to their trip.
But then the coronavirus hit the world, and everything changed.
A mandatory self-quarantine in Israel — and everywhere else
In mid-March, concerns about the coronavirus were reaching a fever pitch. Israel announced a mandatory 14-day self-quarantine for all passengers arriving internationally. At the same time, United Airlines drastically reduced its flights to Israel. As a result, the Allans’ nonstop flight changed to a connection through Newark.
Although the Allans’ trip was still five weeks away, they began to suspect they might not be going. However, they still held some hope that the situation might improve, and they accepted the schedule change.
Every day, the couple checked for updates on the United Airlines website. They heeded the instructions asking that customers not call the airline unless their flight was in the next 72 hours. This would allow passengers with immediate flight cancellation problems to more easily reach customer service.
A friendly gesture from United Airlines… or something else?
With that guidance in mind, the Allans were surprised to receive an email from United Airlines on March 22. The representative asked if the global crisis had caused the couple’s plans to change.
Knowing that United Airlines would owe the duo a full refund if it canceled the flights, Lon asked about the chances of cancellation.
Do you think that United is going to cancel its April 16 NY to Tel Aviv flight? They’ve already canceled their April 16 San Francisco to Tel Aviv nonstop that we booked. Are we “better off” if United cancels rather than if I cancel in terms of receiving a refund? If so, then should I not cancel but wait for United to cancel? Your advice is greatly appreciated.Lon to the United Airlines representative
The answer to all of Lons’ questions was most certainly “Yes.” However, that isn’t the answer he received. The agent told him that to “protect the value of his ticket,” he should cancel the flight. Then he could reschedule after the pandemic.
If you are not going to travel then, yes, the reservation should be canceled. Canceling the reservation will preserve the value of the tickets. You will still have the option to re-book at a later date. Or upon the 12 months from the date of purchase, you can request a refund.United Airlines senior manager, Corporate Support Center
“Does United Airlines owe me a refund if it cancels my flight?”
Not actually seeing the answer to his question in the United Airlines agent’s response, Lon tried once more. He pointed out that by that time, Israel had imposed even stricter coronavirus quarantine rules. All incoming passengers to Israel were required to enter a 14-day government-run quarantine at the traveler’s expense.
Lon expressed his belief that Israel’s new pandemic-inspired quarantine requirements would force United Airlines to cancel his flight.
He asked again if it made more sense to wait to cancel.
The agent responded with yet another nonanswer to his specific question. She then implied that he should cancel to “preserve” the $8,631 value.
If you decide not to use your ticket value for a different trip and want to apply for a refund, then you are able to apply for the refund on December 30, 2020, regardless of the operational status of the EWR(NY)-TLV flight scheduled on April 16, 2020.
Again in order to preserve the value of your tickets, you must cancel the reservation. If you need me to cancel the reservation for you, please let me know.
Thank you for your patience and understanding during this challenging time.United Airlines to Lon
United Airlines “wins”: this passenger cancels the flight
With an uneasy feeling but not willing to risk the loss of over $8,000, Lon agreed to cancel the couple’s flight. The agent informed him that she would email him a confirmation of all the details of their discussion.
Many hours later, though, when the confirmation never arrived, Lon’s uneasy feeling grew. Several days later, when he did finally receive a notice of the canceled flight, it made him more alarmed.
The email contained none of the details that the agent had discussed. It didn’t confirm a future travel credit or mention any possibility of a refund in December. In fact, the notice didn’t actually confirm anything except the cancellation.
“Note that this only says that I MAY have a flight credit,” Lon told me later. “Nothing more.”
Lon’s next email was to our advocacy team.
Flight cancellation confusion: Can our consumer advocacy team help?
When Lon’s request for help landed on my desk, it appeared that his case was one of a passenger who canceled too soon. At the same time I had been repeatedly warning our readers that canceling too soon during the pandemic could have enormous financial consequences.
However, when Lon sent me the entire paper trail between himself and the United agent, a different picture emerged.
Several times, Lon clearly asked the United Airlines agent if it would be better for him just to wait it out. After all, he received no benefit from canceling his flight on March 22. United Airlines received all of the benefits. The airline got to retain the $8,631 that Lon would have preferred to have in his own pocket.
There is little doubt that the United agent knew the answer to Lon’s question. Instead of answering that question, she ignored it and answered something else. This led Lon to cancel his flight prematurely when there was no benefit to him to do so. And, of course, that allowed United Airlines to keep that $8,631 in its pocket instead of his.
The Department of Transportation reiterates that airlines must provide a refund when the airline cancels a flight
In response to the coronavirus and the uptick of canceled flights, the Department of Transportation reaffirmed that the airlines must provide a refund when the flight cancellation is airline-initiated:
The United Airlines agent should have candidly answered Lon’s question. He based his decision to cancel the flight on the employee’s insistence that it was a necessary thing.
Lon told me that he and his wife didn’t want to take a chance of leaving such an enormous investment with United during these uncertain times.
My young wife (hey, we’ve been married “only” for 52 years) is concerned. She thinks that this pandemic may last more than 12 months. So we should get a refund if possible. Can you help?
I hoped I could. It was time to see what United Airlines had to say about this situation.
Asking United Airlines to offer a refund for this flight cancellation
I sent a request over to United Airlines and asked about Lon’s case.
The United Airlines representative who contacted Mr. Allan appears to be suggesting in the email that he must cancel his April 16 flight on that day (March 22) to protect the value of the ticket.
As we know, If United Airlines cancels a flight during the coronavirus pandemic or any other time, then there is no question that a passenger is owed a refund. There would be no reason why Mr. Allan would need to have canceled his flight three weeks ahead of the day of departure.
I’ve been encouraging passengers who want/need a refund to wait it out and not cancel weeks ahead of schedule since there is no benefit to the traveler to cancel early. Obviously, there is no way of knowing if a flight will eventually be canceled weeks ahead of schedule. So it seems unclear why this representative emailed Mr. Allan on March 22 and asked him to cancel.
Mr. Allan and his wife are an elderly couple concerned about the state of the traveling world. They are unsure if they will be able to travel again during the voucher’s validity. They are also concerned about having over $8,000 of their money unavailable to them during this troubling time in history. Mr. Allan has emailed me many times with his fears about losing the value of these tickets. They really need their money back.
Given that United is not permitted to transport this couple to Israel on April 16, even if the flight operates, it seems that they should be offered a choice of a refund or a credit. And in this case, they would like a refund.Michelle to United Airlines
The good news from United Airlines
And within hours, United Airlines came through with good news for the Lons.
Michelle, United Airlines just phoned to [offer these resolution choices]
*If United Airlines cancels the flight from NY to Israel on April 16, they’ll send me a full refund now.
*If United does not cancel our flight, then I may have a refund now — less $500 per ticket cancellation charge.
*Or I may choose a travel certificate for the full amount. We can use it on any UA flights for 24 months from the date of issue.
At this time, we will choose Door Number 1 if available. Otherwise Door Number 2 because being in our mid-70s, we want certainty.Lon Allan
Then just a few weeks later, United Airlines canceled the first leg of their journey. There is no question that this made their entire ticket refundable. After a bit more prodding, United processed the full refund for the couple.
Flight cancellation tips
- Do not cancel before the airline cancels
Many travelers believe that if they are ill, or have some other valid reason not to travel, the airline will refund their ticket. This isn’t true. Please make sure that you will benefit from canceling before you do so. If there isn’t a benefit to canceling, then wait it out no matter what your reason for canceling.
- Don’t be a no-show for your flight
But remember, if the airline does not cancel your flight, you will need to cancel before the day of departure. If you allow yourself to be a no-show you could end up losing the entire value of the ticket.
- Bookmark your airline and other travel provider’s websites
Even today, at the end of 2022, cancellation policies are frequently changing (as are entry requirements to foreign destinations). Check and then check again before you make any decisions about your future flights and other travel plans.
- Make sure you understand the terms of cancellation
Before you cancel your flight, make sure you understand the cancellation terms. If a representative of a company is asking you to agree to something, ask for the specifics in writing. Don’t blindly accept the deal.
- Confirm the expiration dates and terms of the vouchers
If you’re considering accepting a future flight voucher, make sure you understand its terms as well. Carefully check the expiration date. You don’t want to end up on the wrong side of that expiration date later.
- Spend your voucher quickly
A voucher is worth nothing should it expire or the airline, cruise line or other travel provider goes out of business. When booking future travel, purchase a trip insurance policy that includes coverage if your travel provider goes bankrupt. That move can protect you.
- File a complaint with the Department of Transportation
If you think your airline has mishandled your flight cancellation, file a complaint with the Department of transportation. United Airlines was certainly not the only airline to try to saddle passengers with vouchers instead of refunds during the pandemic. If it happened to you, here is how to file a complaint with the DOT.
- If your flight concerns a European airline, file a complaint with the European Commission
Has a European airline mishandled your canceled flight during the pandemic? We know that many foreign governments passed temporary regulations that allowed airlines to grant unwanted vouchers to travelers — even when the carrier canceled a flight. In July 2020, the European Commission issued an enforcement warning to its member states that airlines may not force vouchers upon passengers when a refund is owed. If a European airline ignores or refuses your refund request and grants you a voucher instead, you can file a complaint with the national enforcement body of the European Commission in the state where the flight was to operate. Review Consumer Rescue’s guide to the EU261 for more detailed information. (Michelle Couch-Friedman, Elliott Advocacy)